Assessment: Symptomatic treatment for muscle cramps (an evidence-based review)
Report of the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology
Abstract
Background: A Food and Drug Administration advisory in 2006 warned against the off-label use of quinine sulfate and its derivatives in the treatment of muscle cramps. Physicians are faced with a difficult scenario in choosing a treatment regimen for patients with muscle cramps. This American Academy of Neurology assessment systematically reviews the available evidence on the symptomatic treatment of muscle cramps.
Methods: A total of 563 potential articles were reviewed, of which 24 met the inclusion criteria of prospective trials evaluating the efficacy of a particular treatment on muscle cramps as a primary or secondary outcome.
Results: There are Class I studies showing the efficacy of quinine derivatives for treatment of muscle cramps. However, the benefit is modest and there are adverse effects from published prospective trials as well as case reports. There is one Class II study each to support the use of Naftidrofuryl, vitamin B complex, lidocaine, and diltiazem in the treatment of muscle cramps.
Recommendations: Although likely effective (Level A), quinine derivatives should be avoided for routine use in the management of muscle cramps because of the potential of toxicity, but in select patients they can be considered for an individual therapeutic trial once potential side effects are taken into account. Vitamin B complex, Naftidrofuryl, and calcium channel blockers such as diltiazem are possibly effective and may be considered in the management of muscle cramps (Level C). Further studies are needed to identify agents that are effective and safe for the treatment of muscle cramps.
Muscle cramps are involuntary, generally painful contractions of a muscle or muscle group. Some patients are bothered by very frequent and severe muscle cramps that may be disabling. A cross-sectional prevalence study of 365 outpatients aged 65 or older in the United Kingdom reports that 50% of outpatients report frequent cramps.1 Another review of 515 elderly veterans reports a similar prevalence of 56%, with half having cramps occurring at least once per week.2 When the motor system is stressed, either by a neuromuscular disease or by a physiologic stress such as dehydration or excessive exercise, cramps become more frequent. Muscle cramps are caused by ectopic discharges from nerves or nerve terminals3; therefore, a variety of neuropathic conditions such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), peripheral neuropathies, and cramp-fasciculation syndrome are commonly associated with cramps.4 In addition to neurologic conditions, multiple medical conditions such as hypomagnesemia, hypocalcemia, hypothyroidism, and renal or liver dysfunction may be the cause of cramps. Cramps are also frequent during the last trimester of pregnancy and in athletes such as marathon runners.5,6 When no underlying cause of recurrent muscle cramps can be identified, they are referred to as idiopathic muscle cramps, which can be variable in presentation from patient to patient but are usually most prominent in the lower leg and foot muscles and more evident at night.
Since early reports in the 1930s and 1940s,7 quinine and its derivatives have been the mainstay of therapy for idiopathic muscle cramps. However, a United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Federal Register statement released on December 15, 2006, ordered unapproved quinine drugs to be removed from the market and cautioned consumers about their “off-label” use, citing “665 reports of adverse events with serious outcomes associated with quinine use, including 93 deaths” since 1969.8 Quinine sulfate, in particular Qualaquin®, is the only FDA-approved drug for the treatment of plasmodium falciparum malaria. Use of the drug for any other indication, including muscle cramps, is unapproved. In addition to quinine, a number of other agents have been studied in the treatment of muscle cramps, including antiepileptics, calcium channel blockers, and various vitamins, supplements, and minerals. This assessment addresses the available evidence on the efficacy as well as possible adverse effects of symptomatic treatment of idiopathic muscle cramps.
DESCRIPTION OF THE ANALYTIC PROCESS
The main search strategy was a comprehensive search of MEDLINE and EMBASE from 1950 to May 31, 2008, using the search term “muscle cramp” limited to keywords “therapy,” “drug therapy,” and “prevention and control,” which yielded 558 results in 4 languages (including French, German, Spanish, and English). Additional articles were identified by cross-referencing bibliographies from meta-analyses, review articles, and case reports identified in the initial search, which yielded 5 additional articles. “Muscle cramp” was defined as a sustained, generally painful, involuntary contraction of a muscle or muscle group. “Cramps” alone was not used as a search term due to excessive articles on gynecologic and gastrointestinal cramps.
The abstracts and titles from the 563 articles identified were reviewed, and a study was included if it was a prospective clinical trial with effect on muscle cramps as a primary or secondary outcome. Exclusion criteria were 1) review articles, 2) meta-analyses, 3) case reports or case series that did not involve a treatment, 4) phenomena not consistent with muscle cramps, such as muscle spasms, dystonia, or muscle pains, 5) pregnancy-induced cramps, 6) medical conditions such as hemodialysis and cirrhosis, and 7) cramps due to extreme physiologic stress such as excessive exercise, heat, or dehydration. Cramps secondary to medical conditions were excluded from this analysis because the mechanisms underlying the formation of cramps and often the treatment directed to correct them are distinct from the routine treatment of muscle cramps, and most treatment trials assessing idiopathic cramps also excluded these conditions. Muscle cramps due to myopathies were also excluded due to the distinct underlying mechanisms. Articles excluded after initial review of the 563 titles and abstracts included 13 articles on hemodialysis, 6 articles on cirrhosis, 4 articles on physiologically induced cramps, 11 articles on pregnancy, 39 review articles, and 10 case reports without treatments (total 63 articles). Upon further review, 450 articles were excluded as they were letters or types of publications other than clinical trials or did not deal with muscle cramps or therapy. A total of 50 potential studies were identified for full review. Full review of the articles led to further exclusion of 26 articles that were review articles, letters, or repeat publications of the same clinical trials. The remaining 24 articles were chosen for inclusion in the final review, including one article dealing with nonpharmacologic therapy, 5 open-label pharmacologic trials, and 18 randomized pharmacologic trials.
The final 24 articles involving symptomatic treatment of cramps were distributed to all 3 panel members for critical analysis and classification. Each member of the panel made an independent determination of class of evidence and a final meeting was called to discuss the articles and resolve differences. Data regarding cohort size, completion rate, inclusion and exclusion criteria, treatment and dosage, design of the study, length of study, primary and secondary outcomes, efficacy, and effect size were extracted from each article and tabulated (table e-1 on the Neurology® Web site at www.neurology.org). Each article was classified according to the American Academy of Neurology therapeutic classification of evidence scheme (appendix e-3) and recommendations were based on the level of evidence (appendix e-4).
ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE
Question 1: Are there effective nonpharmacologic treatments for muscle cramps?
Many nonpharmacologic therapies are employed by patients prior to prescription treatment, but there is little evidence to support the use of any of them. Hydration, particularly for exercise-associated cramping, is frequently used by patients; however, there are no formal studies supporting its use. An open-label (Class IV) study from 1979 suggested that stretching affected muscles 3 times a day could reduce cramping.9 A randomized Class II study of 191 patients compared patients who stretched their calves 3 times a day to patients instructed in a sham exercise that involved moving the legs without stretching and found no benefit of stretching on the frequency of cramps or number of cramp-free nights.10 This trial was limited because it had acknowledged difficulties maintaining good patient blinding, and the control patients were given sham exercises that could theoretically provide some benefit.
Conclusion.
Data are insufficient to draw any conclusion on the efficacy of calf stretching in reducing the frequency of muscle cramps.
Recommendation.
None (Level U).
Question 2: Is quinine effective in the treatment of muscle cramps?
Thirteen studies were found involving quinine or quinine derivatives: 2 Class I studies showing efficacy,11,12 4 Class II studies (2 showing efficacy and 2 showing lack of efficacy),13–16 5 Class III studies (2 showing efficacy and 3 showing lack of efficacy),17–21 and 1 Class IV study showing efficacy.22 Only the Class I and II studies are discussed below.
Class I studies.
A randomized trial in 1997 assessed the efficacy of hydroquinine hydrobromide dihydrate 300 mg at night in 112 patients.11 The trial showed a greater reduction in median number of cramps in treated patients compared to placebo (5 fewer cramps, 95% confidence interval [CI] 2–8 cramps) and a reduction of cramp days in treated patients compared to placebo (1 fewer cramp day, 95% CI 0–3 cramp days) during the 3-week study period. The mean number of cramps was reduced by 37%. Another Class I study (n = 109) using 400 mg of quinine showed a modest though significant reduction in the median number of cramps between the run-in and treatment phases (8 cramps, 95% CI 7–10 cramps vs 6 cramps, 95% CI 3–7 cramps).12 The median number of cramps was reduced by 25%. One criticism of this trial was the restrictive inclusion criteria, which excluded patients above age 70 (who are often the patients with difficult-to-treat muscle cramps).
Class II studies.
All 4 Class II studies involved small cohorts (20–43 patients) and none addressed sample size and power calculation.13–16 Two showed efficacy but were limited by inadequate description of baseline characteristics of the treatment and placebo groups,13,14 which does not allow for a fair comparison between the groups and does not control for the potential of inadequate randomization. A trial published in 1994 showed a significant decrease in the mean number of cramps in the group treated with hydroquinine hydrobromide 300 mg in the treatment phase compared to the run-in phase (16.1 cramps, SD 14.7 cramps), whereas the placebo group did not (5 cramps, SD 16.3 cramps).13 A second Class II study found a significant reduction in the mean number of cramps from 44 in the run-in phase to 19.2 ± 5.3 in the treatment group (500 mg quinine sulfate at night) and from 44 to 36.6 ± 6.6 in the placebo group (p = 0.0046). There were also beneficial effects on the number of nights with cramps and sleep disturbance.14
Two other Class II studies were limited by poor patient compliance and low completion rates of 52% and 70%.15,16 Neither showed a significant effect of quinine sulfate (200–300 mg qhs quinine sulfate) on frequency or intensity of muscle cramps.
Adverse effects of quinine and its derivatives.
Common and serious side effects reported in the literature as case reports or series as well as all side effects identified in the 13 studies are listed in the table. A total of 10 minor and 11 serious side effects were identified; the most consistently reported minor side effects were cinchonism (headache and tinnitus) and bitter taste. The most common serious side effects reported were hematologic abnormalities such as hemolytic uremic syndrome–thrombotic thrombocytopenia purpura, disseminated intravascular coagulation, and bleeding diathesis. There were no reports of cinchonism leading to deafness. The frequency of any serious side effect from the studies published in this review was 2% to 4%. We did not find any reports of fatalities from quinine sulfate in any of the studies reviewed in this article. A recent FDA statement reports 93 fatalities and 663 serious adverse events related to quinine; however, no details regarding these events are available for general review.8 Although inclusion of all references for case reports is outside the scope of this article, an article that overviews the majority of common and serious side effects of quinine is referenced here.23
Conclusion.
On the basis of data from 2 Class I studies, quinine derivatives are effective in reducing the frequency of muscle cramps, although the magnitude of benefit is small. Moreover, these agents are associated with serious though uncommon side effects.
Recommendation.
Although likely effective (Level A), the use of quinine derivatives for treatment of muscle cramps should be avoided for routine treatment of cramps. These agents should only be considered when cramps are very disabling, no other agents relieve symptoms, and there is careful monitoring of side effects. They should only be used after informing the patient of the potentially serious side effects.
Question 3: Are there any other pharmacologic treatments effective for the treatment of muscle cramps? Class I studies.
A double-blind randomized controlled trial of 3,600 mg per day of gabapentin in 204 patients with ALS evaluated muscle cramps (among other symptoms such as fasciculations, stiffness, sleeping, and emotionality) using a severity score from 0 to 10 and found no difference between treatment and placebo with respect to any symptom score.24
Class II studies.
A Class II study of 28 patients in 1998 showed that vitamin B complex (including 30 mg per day of vitamin B6) induced remission of muscle cramps in 86% of treated patients who were not known to be vitamin deficient compared to placebo, but the completion rate and compliance were not detailed in the study.25 The use of severity as an outcome measure is also questionable, as almost all other trials use the frequency of cramps as the major outcome measure. A small Class II study using Naftidrofuryl 300 mg BID in 14 patients showed efficacy in the reduction of cramps, but dropouts were not adequately accounted for.26 Naftidrofuryl oxalate is a drug that may enhance utilization of oxygen and glucose in peripheral vascular disease and protection of brain parenchyma during anoxia; it is not available for use in the United States. A trial (n = 27) evaluated the efficacy of vitamin E 800 U qhs vs placebo and found no effect on the mean number of cramps, number of nights with cramps, or sleep disturbance.14 A Class II study using magnesium citrate (900 mg) with a sample size of 58 calculated to detect 25% reduction in cramp frequency at a power of 80% could not conclude that there was a significant improvement in the number of cramps in patients on treatment (p = 0.07),27 and further had a high dropout rate (64%). Another Class II study evaluating the efficacy of magnesium sulfate (dose 300 mg of Mg) with a sample size of 42 calculated to detect 25% reduction in cramp frequency at a power of 90% found that treatment was not superior to placebo for number of cramps, severity, duration, or sleep disturbance.28 A Class II, double-blind, crossover study of 13 patients studied the effects of 30 mg of diltiazem hydrochloride on the number and intensity of cramps in patients experiencing 2 or more cramps per week. The trial showed a reduction (−5.84 to −0.16 cramps per 2-week treatment phase, p = 0.04) in the number of cramps over time in patients treated with diltiazem compared to placebo, with no effect on the intensity of cramps.29
Open-label studies.
Thirty patients treated with gabapentin for 9 months showed a decrease in frequency of cramps in an open-label, unblinded study.30 Eight elderly patients refractory to quinine for treatment of cramps showed response to verapamil in a small open-label study.31 A small study (n = 24) of lidocaine injected directly into the calf was shown to be as effective as quinine in reducing cramps, but there are practical limitations of this mode of administration.32 A recent open-label study on the use of levetiracetam in 20 patients with motor neuron disease showed a reduction in the frequency and severity of muscle cramps over placebo in the 9 months of treatment compared to the 3-month run-in period.33
It is worthwhile to note that although agents such as baclofen, carbamazepine, and oxcarbazepine are frequently used in clinical practice for the management and treatment of muscle cramps, there are no clinical trials in the literature evaluating their efficacy for this indication. A few case reports and reviews commenting on the efficacy of some of these agents in the treatment of particular neuropathic conditions (such as cramp-fasciculation syndrome) have been published.34,35
Also of note, variable amounts of quinine derivatives are present in consumer products such as tonic water. Although there are a few case reports reporting their efficacy in treatment of muscle cramps, there are insufficient data to allow a specific comment on their use.36
Adverse events.
No serious side effects occurred in trials evaluating gabapentin, vitamin B complex, diltiazem, and magnesium for treatment of muscle cramps. Minor side effects such as lightheadedness, nausea, and abdominal discomfort occurred infrequently and with equal frequency in controls and treatment groups in trials of vitamin B25 and magnesium.27,28 Diarrhea was equally common (10%) in magnesium- and placebo-treated patients in one trial27 and slightly more frequent in magnesium-treated patients (30% vs 17%, p = 0.1) in another trial.28 Minor side effects that occurred more frequently with gabapentin treatment included lightheadedness, drowsiness, falls, and limb swelling24 and with Naftidrofuryl treatment included mild gastrointestinal discomfort.26 A small trial of diltiazem did not report any side effects in treated or placebo patients.29
Conclusion.
On the basis of single Class II studies, Naftidrofuryl, vitamin B complex, and diltiazem are possibly effective in the treatment of muscle cramps. Naftidrofuryl is currently not available in the United States. Data regarding the use of magnesium preparations (2 Class II studies) and gabapentin (1 study in ALS) show that these agents are probably not effective in the treatment of muscle cramps.
Recommendation.
Naftidrofuryl, diltiazem, and vitamin B complex may be considered for the treatment of muscle cramps (Level C).
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH
Given the lack of evidence for any convincing treatments for muscle cramps, further research is indicated. Further investigations into the efficacy and adverse effects of medications such as baclofen, carbamazepine, oxcarbazepine, levetiracetam, lidocaine, vitamin B complex, Naftidrofuryl, gabapentin, magnesium, and calcium channel blockers are warranted. Future studies should also include an assessment of the impact of cramps on the quality of life and nonpharmacologic interventions in the treatment of muscle cramps.
DISCLOSURE
Dr. Katzberg has received funding for travel from the Muscular Dystrophy Association. Dr. Khan reports no disclosures. Dr. So receives royalties from the publication of Occupational & Environmental Medicine (Appleton & Lange, 2007) and articles published in UpToDate (2007); receives research support from Pfizer Inc, NeurogesX, Inc., and the NIH (NIEHS R01 [Co-I], NIEHS R01 [Co-I], and NINDS R01 [Site PI]); estimates 10% of his clinical effort is spent on EMG; and holds equity in Satoris, Inc.
DISCLAIMER
This statement is provided as an educational service of the American Academy of Neurology. It is based on an assessment of current scientific and clinical information. It is not intended to include all possible proper methods of care for a particular neurologic problem or all legitimate criteria for choosing to use a specific procedure. Neither is it intended to exclude any reasonable alternative methodologies. The AAN recognizes that specific patient care decisions are the prerogative of the patient and the physician caring for the patient, based on all of the circumstances involved.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The American Academy of Neurology is committed to producing independent, critical and truthful clinical practice guidelines (CPGs). Significant efforts are made to minimize the potential for conflicts of interest to influence the recommendations of this CPG. To the extent possible, the AAN keeps separate those who have a financial stake in the success or failure of the products appraised in the CPGs and the developers of the guidelines. Conflict of interest forms were obtained from all authors and reviewed by an oversight committee prior to project initiation. AAN limits the participation of authors with substantial conflicts of interest. The AAN forbids commercial participation in, or funding of, guideline projects. Drafts of the guideline have been reviewed by at least three AAN committees, a network of neurologists, Neurology® peer reviewers and representatives from related fields. The AAN Guideline Author Conflict of Interest Policy can be viewed at www.aan.com.
Glossary
- ALS
- amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
- CI
- confidence interval
- FDA
- Food and Drug Administration.
Chinese Translation
Files in this Data Supplement:
Chinese Translation - (PDF file)
Footnote
Supplemental data at www.neurology.org
Appendices e-1 through e-4 and table e-1 are available on the Neurology® Web site at www.neurology.org.
Approved by the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee on April 28, 2009; by the Practice Committee on July 1, 2009; and by the AAN Board of Directors on November 9, 2009.
Disclosure: Author disclosures are provided at the end of the article.
Received July 23, 2009. Accepted in final form November 9, 2009.
Supplementary Material
REFERENCES
1.
Abdulla AJ, Jones P, Pearce V. Leg cramps in the elderly: prevalence, drug and disease associations. Int J Clin Pract 1999;53:494–496.
2.
Oboler SK, Prochazka AV, Meyer TJ. Leg symptoms in outpatient veterans. West J Med 1991;155:256–259.
3.
Layzer RB. The origin of muscle fasciculations and cramps. Muscle Nerve 1994;17:1243–1249.
4.
Miller TM, Layzer RB. Muscle cramps. Muscle Nerve 2005;32:431–442.
5.
Schwellnus MP. Muscle cramping in the marathon: aetiology and risk factors. Sports Med 2007;37:364–367.
6.
Salvatore CA. Leg cramp syndrome in pregnancy. Obstet Gynecol 1961;17:634–639.
7.
Moss HK, Herrman LG. The use of quinine for relief of “night cramps” in the extremities. JAMA 1940;115:1358–1359.
8.
Food and Drug Administration, Department of Health and Human Services. Drug products containing quinine; enforcement action dates. Federal Register 2006;71:75557–75560.
9.
Daniell HW. Simple cure for nocturnal leg cramps. N Engl J Med 1979;301:216.
10.
Coppin RJ, Wicke DM, Little PS. Managing nocturnal leg cramps: calf-stretching exercises and cessation of quinine treatment: a factorial randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2005;55:186–191.
11.
Jansen PH, Veenhuizen KC, Wesseling AI, de Boo T, Verbeek AL. Randomised controlled trial of hydroquinine in muscle cramps. Lancet 1997;349:528–532.
12.
Diener HC, Dethlefsen U, Dethlefsen-Gruber S, Verbeek P. Efficacy of quinine in treating muscle cramps: a double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel-group, multicentre trial. Int J Clin Pract 2002;56:243–246.
13.
Jansen PH, Veenhuizen KC, Verbeek AL, Straatman H. Effectiveness of hydroquinine in preventing frequent ordinary muscle cramp outlasts actual administration. J Neurol Sci 1994;122:157–161.
14.
Connolly PS, Shirley EA, Wasson JH, Nierenberg DW. Treatment of nocturnal leg cramps: a crossover trial of quinine vs vitamin E. Arch Intern Med 1992;152:1877–1880.
15.
Warburton A, Royston JF, O'Neill CJA, et al. A quinine a day keeps the leg cramps away? Br J Clin Pharmacol 1987;23:459–465.
16.
Sidorov J. Quinine sulfate for leg cramps: does it work? J Am Geriatr Soc 1993;41:498–500.
17.
Fung MC, Holbrook JH. Placebo-controlled trial of quinine therapy for nocturnal leg cramps. West J Med 1989;151:42–44.
18.
Lim SH. Randomised double-blind trial of quinine sulphate for nocturnal leg cramp. Br J Clin Pract 1986;40:462.
19.
Jones K, Castleden CM. A double blind comparison of quinine sulphate and placebo in muscle cramps. Age Ageing 1983;12:155–158.
20.
Dunn NR. Effectiveness of quinine for night cramps. Br J Gen Pract 1993;43:127–128.
21.
Woodfield R, Goodyear-Smith F, Arroll B. N-of-1 trials of quinine efficacy in skeletal muscle cramps of the leg. Br J Gen Pract 2005;55:181–185.
22.
Parrow A, Samuelsson SM. Use of chloroquine phosphate–a new treatment for spontaneous leg cramps. Acta Med Scand 1967;181:237–244.
23.
Bateman DN, Dyson EH. Quinine toxicity. Adv Drug React 1986;4:215–233.
24.
Miller RG, Moore DH, Gelinas DF, et al. Phase III randomized trial of gabapentin in patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Neurology 2001;56:843–848.
25.
Chan P, Huang TY, Chen YJ, Huang WP, Liu YC. Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of the safety and efficacy of vitamin B complex in the treatment of nocturnal leg cramps in elderly patients with hypertension. J Clin Pharmacol 1998;38:1151–1154.
26.
Young JB, Connolly MJ. Naftidrofuryl treatment for rest cramp. Postgrad Med J 1993;69:624–626.
27.
Roffe C, Sills S, Crome P, Jones P. Randomised, cross-over, placebo controlled trial of magnesium citrate in the treatment of chronic persistent leg cramps. Med Sci Monit 2002;8:CR326–CR330.
28.
Frusso R, Zarate M, Augustovski F, Rubinstein A. Magnesium for the treatment of nocturnal leg cramps: a crossover randomized trial. J Fam Pract 1999;48:868–871.
29.
Voon WC, Sheu SH. Diltiazem for nocturnal leg cramps. Age Ageing 2001;30:91–92.
30.
Serrao M, Rossi P, Cardinali P, Valente G, Parisi L, Pierelli F. Gabapentin treatment for muscle cramps: an open-label trial. Clin Neuropharmacol 2000;23:45–49.
31.
Baltodano N, Gallo BV, Weidler DJ. Verapamil vs quinine in recumbent nocturnal leg cramps in the elderly. Arch Intern Med 1988;148:1969–1970.
32.
Prateepavanich P, Kupniratsaikul V, Charoensak T. The relationship between myofascial trigger points of gastrocnemius muscle and nocturnal calf cramps. J Med Assoc Thai 1999;82:451–459.
33.
Bedlack RS, Pastula DM, Hawes J, Heydt D. Open-label pilot trial of levetiracetam for cramps and spasticity in patients with motor neuron disease. Amyotroph Lateral Scler 2008;26:1–6.
34.
Tahmoush AJ, Alonso RJ, Tahmoush GP, Heiman-Patterson TD. Cramp-fasciculation syndrome: a treatable, hyperexcitable peripheral nerve disorder. Neurology 1991;41:1021–1024.
35.
Lagueny A. Cramp-fasciculation syndrome. Rev Neurol 2005;161:1260–1266.
36.
Brasic JR. Should people with nocturnal leg cramps drink tonic water and bitter lemon? Psychol Rep 1999;84:355–367.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Neurology®
Volume 74 • Number 8 • February 23, 2010
Pages: 691-696
Copyright
© 2010.
Publication History
Published online: February 22, 2010
Published in print: February 23, 2010
Notes
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download Citations
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
Cited By
- Muscle Cramps in Outpatients with Liver Diseases in Tokyo, Japan, Medicina, 59, 9, (1506), (2023).https://doi.org/10.3390/medicina59091506
- Pickle Juice Intervention for Cirrhotic Cramps Reduction: The PICCLES Randomized Controlled Trial, American Journal of Gastroenterology, 117, 6, (895-901), (2022).https://doi.org/10.14309/ajg.0000000000001781
- Muscle cramps and contractures: causes and treatment, Practical Neurology, 23, 1, (23-34), (2022).https://doi.org/10.1136/pn-2022-003574
- Treatment of Muscle Cramps in Patients With Cirrhosis of Liver: A Systematic Review, Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hepatology, 12, 3, (980-992), (2022).https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jceh.2021.10.147
- A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicenter study assessing the efficacy of magnesium oxide monohydrate in the treatment of nocturnal leg cramps, Nutrition Journal, 20, 1, (2021).https://doi.org/10.1186/s12937-021-00747-9
- Fasciculations in Children, Pediatric Neurology, 125, (40-47), (2021).https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2021.08.008
- Pathophysiology and Treatment of Non-motor Dysfunction in Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis, CNS Drugs, 35, 5, (483-505), (2021).https://doi.org/10.1007/s40263-021-00820-1
- Association between physical activity and Nocturnal Leg Cramps in patients over 60 years old: a case-control study, Scientific Reports, 10, 1, (2020).https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-59312-9
- Case Studies in Management of Muscle Cramps, Neurologic Clinics, 38, 3, (679-696), (2020).https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ncl.2020.03.011
- Schlafbezogene Beinmuskelkrämpfe, Handbuch Schlafmedizin, (389-393), (2020).https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-3-437-21321-2.00046-6
- See more
Loading...
View Options
View options
Full Text
View Full TextGet Access
Login options
Check if you have access through your login credentials or your institution to get full access on this article.
Personal login Institutional LoginPurchase Options
Purchase this article to get full access to it.
We thank Drs. Mauskop, Rison, Mahajan, and Engel for their comments.
The term "symptomatic" in our assessment refers to the symptom of muscle cramps rather than implying an underlying cause for cramps such as magnesium deficiency. As stated in the methods, [1] we purposefully excluded articles dealing with treatment of muscle cramps during pregnancy and due to medical conditions such as cirrhosis and hemodialysis, which likely have distinct mechanisms of action from idiopathic muscle cramps. Full coverage of these diverse conditions was outside the scope of our assessment. A Cochrane review of the treatment of muscle cramps during pregnancy does support the use of magnesium lactate or citrate in this particular clinical circumstance. [11] We would not recommend extending this practice to all patients experiencing muscle cramps simply because magnesium is an inexpensive or benign drug, particularly when 2 Class II studies refute its efficacy. [12,13]
We thank Drs. Rison, Mahajan, and Engel for sharing their experience with primrose oil, baker's yeast, and clonazepam. In our review, we did not encounter any human trials using primrose or baker's yeast, and none of the studies quoted by Dr. Rison appear to monitor muscle cramps. There is a surprising lack of published evidence for GABAergic agents and antiepileptic drugs in our review, which are drugs frequently used by clinicians—including ourselves—for the treatment of cramps.
As stated in the Recommendations for Future Research, well-designed studies on the pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments of cramps are needed, and these should include alternative medicines. We hope that the recognition of the gap in published evidence will stimulate much-needed research in the treatment of this common condition.
References
11. Young GL, Jewell D. Interventions for leg cramps in pregnancy. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2002;(1):CD000121.
12. Roffe C, Sills S, Crome P, Jones P. Randomised, crossover, placebo controlled trial of magnesium citrate in the treatment of chronic persistent leg cramps. Med Sci Monit 2002;8:CR326 –CR330.
13. Frusso R, Zarate M, Augustovski F, Rubinstein A. Magnesium for the treatment of nocturnal leg cramps: a crossover randomized trial. J Fam Pract 1999;48:868–871.
Disclosures: See original article for full disclosure list.
Painful muscle cramps (PMC's) are usually due to aberrant repetitive discharges of lower motor neurons, causing intermittent, or nearly constant, painful contractions of larger or smaller groups of muscle fibers. Initial management is a) prohibiting all caffeine and other stimulants, and b) trying to substitute for â-agonists and other adrenergics. Based on multiple N-of-1 repeated on-off studies of >100 PMC patients over 10 years, we find clonazepam (Klonopin) much superior in benefit:side-effects ratio compared to the 2 FDA-approved medications, diltiazem and vitamin B complex, which were rated as "possibly effective" in the new AAN Guidelines for treating PMC's. The guideline does not even mention clonazepam [8].
Controlled trials are helpful but do not provide all the information useful for clinical management. Absence of a Guidelines benefit is not absence of relevant benefit. Numerous "N-of-1" experiences with carefully-monitored individual patients are also pertinent.
Very-low-dose clonazepam, a benzodiazepine, is our choice for treating PMC's (e.g. in peripheral neuropathy or ALS), which are generated by a disturbance anywhere in the lower motor neuron: soma, axon-schwann cell complex, or distal axonal twigs [9]. PMC's are often worse at the end of an especially active day or during that night. They can cause "painful insomnia" (difficulty achieving sleep and awakening during sleep). Evening or bedtime clonazepam can decrease intensity and frequency of cramps, and be mildly soporific. With very-low doses, patients typically have more restful nights and no sluggishness the next morning. Clonazepam 0.25, 0.5 or1.0 mg h.s. has, without significant side-effects, benefited >80% of patients, referred to our tertiary center, who were previously unresponsive to one or more relaxing agents, e.g. pregabalin, duloxetine or gabapentin, and hypnotics. Complex trials are not required to demonstrate clonazepam's effectiveness. No drug build-up is needed. At a given dose, it either provides relief the first night -- e.g., "the first good night's sleep I've had in months" -- or it doesn't. Some patients with troublesome daytime muscle cramps, or fasciculations, benefit from 0.25-0.5mg during the morning without engendering sleepiness.
Pharmacologically, clonazepam acts especially on benzodiazepine receptors, integrated in pentameric GABA-gated chloride channels (the GABAA receptor), to facilitate GABA-mediated chloride conductance, causing hyperpolarization (inhibition of excitability) -- and conceptually, perhaps it also acts on peripheral-type benzodiazepine receptors. The locus of clonazepam's benefit for cramps is uncertain: possibly on motor axons prejunctionally or junctionally, or on myofiber T-tubule dihydropyridine-receptor excitation-contraction coupling mechanisms [10], or perhaps on spinal neurons,
Although clonazepam is not "FDA-approved" for PMC's, it can be effective and safe. In our experience, it has benefited patients, who are grateful for less pain and better sleep.
References
8. Katzberg HD, Khan AH, So YT. Assessment: Symptomatic treatment for muscle cramps (an evidence-based review). Neurology 2010;74:691-6.
9. Engel WK. Multi-Microcramps (MMC) Syndrome: a new pathogenic concept of subtle lower motor-neuron (LMN) lability causing very disturbing, continuous muscle pains, sometimes gratifyingly treatable – but often misinterpreted as mysterious "fibromyalgia" or "psychogenic". Neurology 2010; 74(Suppl 2): A465.
10. Chiou LC, Chang CC. Pharmacological relevance of peripheral type benzodiazepine receptors on motor nerve and skeletal muscle. Br J Pharmacol 1994;112: 257-261.
Disclosure; the authors report no disclosures.
I read with interest the recent evidence-based review by Katzberg et al. regarding the treatment of muscle cramps. [1] I was surprised to read that the dietary supplements primrose oil (Efamol) and brewer's yeast (EpiCor) were not mentioned.
Primrose oil is a rich source of omega-6 fatty acids used for certain neurologic conditions including chronic fatigue syndrome (myalgic encephalomyelitis) on the biochemical basis that it ultimately promotes production of membrane-stabilizing fatty acids (lipophilic pentacyclic triterpenes) with anti-oxidant and free-radical scavenging properties. [4]
Furthermore, primrose oil has also been used in diabetic peripheral neuropathy [5] and shown to improve nerve conduction velocities in animal models. [6] In addition, it has improved vasa nervorum perfusion secondary to increased endoneurial capillary density from angiogenesis. [7]
Similarly, brewer's yeast has been shown to improve myalgias and other symptoms associated with seasonal influenza vaccine. [8] On the basis of this data, I have used both primrose oil and brewer's yeast in treating muscle cramps from various neuropathic conditions including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and diabetic peripheral neuropathy with reasonable success.
Although unpublished, I suspect that these complementary alternative medicinal agents— with excellent side effect profiles— are used for the treatment of symptomatic muscle cramps.
References
4. Puri BK. Long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids and the pathophysiology of myalgic encephalomyelitis (chronic fatigue syndrome). J Clin Pathol 2007;60:122-124.
5. Halat KM, Dennehy CE. Botanicals and dietary supplements in diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Am Board Fam Pract 2003;16:47-57.
6. Cameron NE, Cotter MA, Robertson S. Essential fatty acid diet supplementation. Effects on peripheral nerve and skeletal muscle function and capillarization in streptozocin-induced diabetic rats. Diabetes 1991;40:532-539.
7. Ford I, Cotter MA, Cameron NE, Greaves M. The effects of treatment with alpha-lipoic acid or evening primrose oil on vascular hemostatic and lipid risk factors, blood flow, and peripheral nerve conduction in the streptozotocin- diabetic rat. Metabolism 2001;50:868-875.
8. Moyad MA. Brewer's/baker's yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and preventive medicine: Part II. Urol Nurs. 2008;28:73-75.
Disclosure: Dr. Rison is an Associate Editor for Journal of Medical Case Reports, Case Reports in Neurology and was previously an Associate Editor for Cases Journal.
Katzberg et al. analyzed two negative papers regarding the use of magnesium citrate for the treatment of muscle cramps. [1]
They omitted a positive double-blind trial where proprietary "primarily magnesium lactate, magnesium citrate" product was used. [2] However, "symptomatic" in the paper by Katzenberg et al. implies that no underlying cause has been detected, while muscle cramps are a typical symptom of magnesium deficiency [3] and it would be more appropriate to consider hypomagnesimia as a specific, correctable cause.
Due to the benign nature and low cost of magnesium, empiric therapy with magnesium in all patients may be worthwhile. However, oral magnesium is often poorly absorbed and lack of a response to treatment does not rule out the presence of magnesium deficiency. Serum levels are not useful because only 1% of magnesium in the body is extracellular and there is poor correlation between serum and the more accurate RBC or ionized magnesium levels.
Since ionized levels are not commercially available and RBC magnesium levels are fairly expensive (about $80 US), an empirical trial with magnesium oxide, magnesium citrate, or a chelated form of magnesium is warranted. However, in severe cases, measuring RBC magnesium levels and administration of IV magnesium sulfate can be considered.
References
1. Katzberg HD, Khan AH, So YT. Assessment: Symptomatic treatment for muscle cramps (an evidence-based review): Report of the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology 2010;74:691-696.
2. Dahle L, Berg G, Hammar M, Hurtig M, Larsson L. The effect of oral magnesium substitution on pregnancy-induced leg cramps. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 1995:173;175-180.
3. Coghlan HC, Natello G. Erythrocyte magnesium in symptomatic patients with primary mitral valve prolapse: relationship to symptoms, mitral leaflet thickness, joint hypermobility and autonomic regulation. Magnes Trace Elem. 1991-1992;10:205-214.
Disclosure: Dr. Mauskop owns patents for Migralex and is part owner of Migralex, Inc.